September 15, 2021
The Tauranga Ratepayers’ Alliance have today launched an online survey aimed at gathering public feedback on proposed ‘game-changing’ decisions Tauranga City will be faced with in the coming months.
Tauranga Ratepayers’ Alliance Spokesperson Philip Brown says it’s important the community have their voices heard, as these opportunities are rare under this unelected Commission.
“Unfortunately, the Commissioners aren’t going to listen to the people of Tauranga, but we will.
Brown says it’s vital people have a say on major issues like the proposed Three Waters reforms, as they are likely to have a direct impact on how people live their day-to-day lives.
“The Commissioners seem intent on pushing ahead with their agenda, which is now being forced upon local residents without any say in the matter.
“We want to send them a message, we want them to know what the people of Tauranga really think
“With the Minister leaving the door open to extending the term of the Commissioners beyond October 2022 with no restoration of local democracy in sight, it’s vital the community is heard before it’s too late.”
www.taurangacommunityfeedback.com
September 14, 2021
Mahuta might cancel elections in Tauranga … again
Local Government Minister Nanaia Mahuta has refused to guarantee the return of democracy to New Zealand’s fifth largest city next year.
Speaking to Q&A’s Jack Tame on Sunday, Mahuta was unwilling to comment on whether Tauranga’s elections would be cancelled, instead saying the Commissioners she appointed at the end of 2020 were doing a good job.
Tame prompted Mahuta to offer a “flat out guarantee” that Tauranga would have local body elections next year. She refused.
Mahuta went on to claim her appointees had increased Council’s connectivity with the community.
This comes just two weeks after the Council admitted less than 30 people attended their ‘drop-in’ consultation centres regarding proposed changes in the Representation Review, something the Tauranga Ratepayers’ Alliance says is unacceptable.
“The people of Tauranga have very limited means through which to communicate with those who make decisions in the Council Chambers.
“The decision makers are unelected, aren’t there on a publicly supported mandate, and are unaccountable to the public.
The Minister’s claim that the people of Tauranga have “appreciated” the work of the un-elected Commission is a fallacy too, says Tauranga Ratepayers’ Alliance spokesperson Ben Sokimi.
“The people of our city are suffering unprecedented increases to their rates bills and simply aren’t seeing the benefits
“Nanaia Mahuta should ask Winston Peters if she could borrow his ‘NO’ sign, because every time she’s asked about the prospect of democracy returning to Tauranga she doesn’t have much else to say
“A return to democracy is what is needed, and what is right for our city
“It’s time for the Government to end the charade and return democracy to the people
July 28, 2021
WOW. Hundreds turned out on Monday in the pouring rain to fight for our City and call out the unelected Commissioners who are fundamentally changing our city.
But democracy ended at the door of the Council chambers. Despite huge opposition to the massive rate hikes, and demands for less waste and more transparency, the unelected Commissioners still went ahead and approved Anne Tolley's radical Long-term Plan.
The Elite in the Tower and the People in the Square
The irony was not lost in the fact that the chanting of hundreds of local ratepayers outside could be heard while Jordan Williams and Kim Williams delivered our message to the unelected Commissioners.
Click here to listen to the message delivered to Commissioners.
The media coverage speaks for itself
Bay of Plenty Times: Tauranga Ratepayers' Alliance protest starts walk to council
Bay of Plenty Times: Tauranga Ratepayers' Alliance protest against 22pc rates rises achieves 'great' turnout
Bay of Plenty Times: Green light for 15pc rates rise as Tauranga City approves controversial Long-term Plan
Sunlive: Protestors descend on Tauranga Council
Sunlive: Commissioner reacts to ratepayer protests
Meanwhile the Council's sockpuppets are in spin mode
The crowds that joined us yesterday are quite the contrast to groups like the Chamber of Commerce who are calling for the Commissioner's terms to be extended!
The Chamber's CEO, Matt Cowley, told RNZ that a return to democracy would be 'risky'. See Radio NZ coverage: Tauranga leaders concerned about plans to reinstate councillors in 2022
Of course Mr Cowley did not disclose that the Chambers largest funder is none other than the Council Commissioners he is defending! In fact when we approached Mr Cowley to ask why he wasn't backing democracy, he said elections are a just a 'small part' of local democracy. Weird. We thought being able kick out local leaders the very essence of democracy...
The thing is, we'd much rather have ratbag politicians who we can get rid of, than ratbag Commissioners and officials who report to Wellington and we cannot fire!
July 15, 2021
You may have seen in the media last week that we exposed previously secret legal advice suggesting Nanaia Mahuta acted unlawfully when she sacked the City Council and appointed Commissioners.
Your support made our efforts to reveal this possible. But our work isn't done.
Join the protest for fairer rates!
On Monday 26 July, the Tauranga City Council will release its finalised Long Term Plan. We are sad to report that despite the huge opposition, Anne Tolley still plans on huge rate increases: 17% for residential and 33% for commercial next year alone, impacting every household and business in Tauranga.
Hundreds of people have attended meetings over the past few months and made their voices very clear: they simply cannot afford these proposed rate hikes.
All Tauranga ratepayers and residents are now encouraged to join the protest on Monday 26 July, and take the message directly to Council.
Join your neighbours to show the Council you are rightly concerned, and to demand fairer rates, less waste and more transparency.
Protest details
Monday 26 July
12.30 PM
Strand Carpark (4 Dive Crescent)
RSVP preferred - click here
Park and Ride buses will be operating from 11.30 AM at Sulphur Point Carpark
July 02, 2021
The Tauranga Ratepayers' Alliance is releasing a legal opinion from one of the country’s top law firms, obtained under the Official Information Act, which suggests that Local Government Minister Nanaia Mahuta acted unlawfully when she sacked the City Council and appointed Commissioners.
The appointment in February cancelled elections scheduled in March for a new Mayor and Councillors, removing the right of Tauranga residents to choose their own leaders. An independent review of the Minister's decision by law firm Russell McVeagh, released under the Official Information Act to the Tauranga Ratepayers’ Alliance, "identified several issues with the Minister's decision from a public law perspective" including:
• that the Minister failed to adequately consider lesser alternatives, such as the appointment of a Crown Manager, and as such "does not meet the statutory requirement in the [Local Government Act 2002]." Should the issue proceed to Court, Russell McVeagh has suggested: "a court would likely expect a robust assessment of lesser interventions to have been first undertaken;
• the information provided by the Department of Internal Affairs to the Minister was arguably "incorrect, misleading or insufficient for the purpose of making the decision that a Commission should be appointed;" and
• strong criticism of the recommendation by Peter Winder, chair of the Review and Observer Team, that a Commission be appointed because he did not inform the Council nor allow Councillors the opportunity to respond to it, as required under his terms of reference. Russell McVeagh found this breach "could potentially impact on the integrity and validity of the Minister's Decision" and could result in Winder's recommendation being "set aside by a court on natural justice grounds."
The advice is being released by the Tauranga Ratepayers’ Alliance and is available at www.taurangaratepayers.nz/legal_advice.
In reaction to the release of the legal analysis Tauranga Ratepayers' Alliance spokeswoman Dawn Kiddie says, "this analysis provides a chilling insight into the casual way the Minister stripped our community of democracy. The release of the advice will be embarrassing for Wellington. It shows how vulnerable the Commissioners are to legal challenge. But the way to fix this is easy: Tauranga should be returned to democracy with fresh elections held."
May 13, 2021
The Tauranga Ratepayers’ Alliance is urging the Commission to stop the spin and come clean on its proposed rates hike. Ratepayers’ Alliance spokesperson Kim Williams said:
“The Commission’s claim that they are proposing to increase rates by only ‘one dollar per day’ or ‘two bottles of milk per week’ is misleading at best.”
“Tauranga City Council’s Long-term Plan summary document conveniently leaves out the proposed 30% increase in water rates – an additional $118 per year for the average user. It also neglects to mention the increase to user-fees by an average of 17% which would add a further $100 per year to a resident’s cost of living.”
“That’s an increase of $612 or 172 bottles of two-litre milk per year for a typical household; half of ratepayers will be paying more than that and some significantly more.”
“Tauranga average residential rates are already among the highest in the country. Now, commercial ratepayers are facing a massive rates increase of between 27% and 41%. It won’t just be a question of milk bottles for them; they’re looking at the cost of a whole farm.”
“We need an honest conversation about what the Commissioner’s proposals are going to cost Tauranga families. Undercooking the figures, or deliberately skipping over the measures the Council wants to take to reach deeper into our pockets, does informed debate a disservice. The Commissioners appear too willing to act like politicians, rather than a-political bureaucrats we’re paying them the big bucks for.”
May 07, 2021
The Tauranga Ratepayers’ Alliance is exposing plans that will see the cost of consultants and contractors employed by Tauranga City Council skyrocket from $16.5 million last year to $23.3 million this year. Commenting on the information – released to the Ratepayers’ Alliance under official information law – Ratepayers’ Alliance spokesman Matthew Gill said:
“This is yet another burden on ratepayers who are already footing the huge increase in Council staff salaries from $66.3 to $80.5 million this year.”
“It was particularly misleading of Commissioner Stephen Selwood to earlier defend skyrocketing Council staff salaries by suggesting this would avoid contractor costs when, at the very same time, he and his colleagues were approving a massive increase in contractor and consultant costs in the draft budget.”
“Residents expected that Commissioners would work toward a more effective and efficient Council, but instead the opposite is happening. We’re witnessing a blowout in both the size of the Council bureaucracy and the consultants that make a living from it.”
May 03, 2021
Tauranga ratepayers have come together to form a City-wide voice to champion a better deal and more transparency for Tauranga ratepayers. The Tauranga Ratepayers’ Alliance launches today.
We are a combined initiative of local residents, chairs and former chairs of Ratepayers’ Associations, civic leaders, and local members of the Taxpayers’ Union, who have formed the new Ratepayers’ Alliance in response to the appointment of unelected commissioners in place of elected councillors.
Ratepayers’ Alliance spokesperson Dawn Kiddie says, “There is growing discontent with decisions taken by Commissioners that ratepayers feel they have no control over, such as increasing staff salaries from $66 million to $80 million next year. The Ratepayers’ Alliance will stand up against Tauranga City Council’s wasteful spending, poor financial management, and the unprecedented rates increase.”
New Zealand Taxpayers’ Union Co-founder Jordan Williams says, “Over the last few months the Taxpayers' Union has been approached by numerous local Tauranga supporters calling for a dedicated voice for fiscal prudence, and transparency. Without recourse to elections to kick the decision-makers out, a strong voice for ratepayers is more important than ever.”
If you are a Tauranga resident or ratepayer, you are encouraged to join for free at www.taurangaratepayers.nz, or at the launch event on Wednesday 26 May at Club Mount Maunganui from 5.30pm, with keynote speaker Simon Bridges and MC Peter Williams.
“Nanaia Mahuta and Anne Tolly have an expensive and unconstrained spending agenda for Tauranga. We need to take back control of our city – with numbers, a strong voice, and organisation,” says Kim Williams, a member of the Steering Group.
